Why bigamy is a crime? Bigamy, generally defined as the act of marrying one person while already legally married to another, has been the subject of considerable legal and social scrutiny throughout history. Although the idea of multiple marriages may seem acceptable or even desirable in some cultures or contexts, it is a criminal offense in many countries around the world, including most states in the US, and European countries such as Spain, Germany and the United Kingdom. United.
But why is this so? What are the underlying reasons for criminalizing bigamy? In this article, we will examine the historical, legal and social roots of the prohibition of bigamy, with the goal of better understanding why, despite changing social norms and values, bigamy remains a crime in many jurisdictions.
Why bigamy is a crime?
History of bigamy legislation. Bigamy legislation has deep roots in human history. Monogamy has been the norm in many cultures since ancient times, and this preference has influenced the formation of laws in numerous societies.
In ancient Rome, for example, bigamy was unacceptable. The Romans valued monogamy as a central principle of their society, and bigamy was often severely punished. In early Christianity, bigamy was also considered a sin, and the Catholic Church has maintained a strong stance against polygamy and bigamy throughout history.
In the Anglo-Saxon context, laws against bigamy began to form in earnest during medieval times in England. These laws were developed from the influence of the Catholic Church and the social norms of the time, which viewed monogamy as the only acceptable type of marriage.
In the United States, bigamy laws were introduced in the 18th and 19th centuries. These laws became stricter over time, especially in response to the polygamous practices of some religious groups, such as the Mormons in the 19th century.
In many parts of the world, bigamy became a crime during the 20th century. The United Nations has declared bigamy an act of discrimination against women, and many countries have followed this line of thinking in their legislation.
In short, the history of bigamy legislation is rooted in cultural, religious, and social norms that have favored monogamy as the acceptable model of marriage. Bigamy has historically been seen as a transgression against these norms, and this perception has influenced the formation of laws that criminalize it.
Legal reasons for the prohibition of bigamy
Laws prohibiting bigamy have been designed with several legal objectives in mind. Below are some of the most notable justifications:
1. Protection of legal rights and benefits associated with marriage: Marriage grants couples a series of legal rights and benefits, including access to social security benefits, inheritance rights, property rights and more. Bigamy can complicate the distribution of these rights and benefits, especially in the case of a divorce or the death of a spouse.
2. Prevention of fraud and complicated litigation: Bigamy laws help prevent marriage fraud, where a person might marry multiple people for financial or other benefits. Additionally, bigamy can lead to complicated litigation in cases of divorce, child custody, property division, and more. Maintaining monogamy simplifies these legal processes.
3. Informed consent and transparency in marital relationships: Bigamy laws are also designed to protect the principle of informed consent in marriage. That is, both parties must have full knowledge and agreement about the conditions of their marriage. In many cases of bigamy, one or both parties may not be fully aware of the existence of other marriages.
These are just some of the legal reasons for the prohibition of bigamy. Generally, these laws have been established to protect the rights and benefits of spouses in marriage, maintain transparency and consent in marital relationships, and prevent legal complications and potential fraud.
Social reasons for the prohibition of bigamy
In addition to legal reasons, there are several social reasons for the prohibition of bigamy. These are based on how bigamy can affect family structure, relationship dynamics, and the well-being of those involved. Here are some of the most notable considerations:
1. Impact on family structure and power dynamics: In many societies, monogamous marriage is considered the basis of family structure. Bigamy, especially when it involves a person with multiple spouses who have no other marital relationships, can disrupt this structure. It can also create power imbalances, as a person in a central position may have more control or influence over others.
2. Children’s well-being: There are concerns about how bigamy can affect the well-being of children. In polygamous families, there may be difficulties in providing sufficient care and resources to all children. Complications may also arise in terms of family relationships and kinship dynamics.
3. Tension between individual freedom and social norms: Bigamy can be seen as a challenge to established social norms. Although individual freedom is an important value, there is also a social interest in maintaining certain norms, including the monogamous family structure. This tension between individual freedom and social norms is an important reason for the social prohibition of bigamy.
These social reasons for banning bigamy reflect how bigamy can impact society and individual relationships broadly. However, it is important to remember that these are generalizations and that reality can vary significantly depending on the specific context.
Debate and criticism of bigamy laws
Laws prohibiting bigamy are not exempt from criticism and debate. Here are some of the most common arguments:
Arguments in favor of liberalizing bigamy laws
1. Freedom of choice and personal autonomy. Some argue that people should have the freedom to choose the family structure that best suits their needs and desires, including the possibility of having multiple spouses.
2. Cultural and religious diversity: In some cultures and religions, polygamy is an accepted and respected practice. By prohibiting bigamy, these laws can be seen as imposing a Western, monogamous view of marriage.
3. Legal recognition of existing realities: In some societies, bigamy occurs de facto, although it is not legally recognized. Some argue that legally recognizing these marriages could offer protections and rights to the spouses and children of these unions.
Arguments against liberalizing bigamy laws
1. Protecting the rights of spouses and children: Critics argue that bigamy can lead to abuse and power imbalances in relationships, and that it can be harmful to children.
2. Legal complexity: Bigamy can complicate laws regarding marriage, divorce, inheritance and other legal issues. This could create an additional burden on the legal system.
3. Preservation of social norms: Some view monogamy as an important social norm that must be preserved. They argue that liberalization of bigamy laws could undermine this norm.
It is important to note that this debate is complex and that each argument has its own strengths and weaknesses. Furthermore, perceptions of bigamy can vary widely depending on cultural, religious, and personal context.
Conclusion: Why is bigamy a crime?
Bigamy, the act of marrying more than one person at a time, is an issue that has been legislated and debated in many societies throughout history. Despite changing social norms and values, bigamy remains a crime in many jurisdictions. The reasons for this are multiple and vary from legal considerations and protections to the impact on social and family structure.
In legal terms, the prohibition of bigamy helps protect the rights and benefits associated with marriage, prevent potential fraud, and maintain transparency and consent in marital relationships. Socially, the ban is justified by the potential impact on family structure and power dynamics, the well-being of children, and the tension between individual freedom and social norms.
However, there are also arguments against the criminalization of bigamy, which emphasize personal autonomy, respect for cultural and religious diversity, and recognition of existing realities. This suggests that the bigamy debate is dynamic and far from resolved.
Looking ahead, trends in social norms and values, as well as changes in family structures, could influence how bigamy is perceived and legislated. Regardless of which path society takes, it is essential that any discussion of bigamy takes into account the impact on everyone involved, and that the rights and well-being of all parties are respected.
Read also: Is bigamy legal in Florida?; WHAT IS BIGAMY IN UNITED STATES?; Is bigamy legal in the United States?
Valuable external resource: Wikipedia
This post is also available in:
English 
Deutsch (German) 
Español (Spanish)
